Background:
1.    1978—both houses of Congress find that litigation and disputes should be consolidated in b/r court.
2.    Northern Pipeline:  S. Ct. finds that broad jurisdiction for b/r judges is ok, but you can’t give it all to article I judges.  This case involve a lawsuit against someone who had no claim in b/r, but the trustee went after him on a K claim and brought that claim in b/r court.  S. Ct. says no way—such a case needs to be before an article III judge.
3.    Granfinanciera:  Defendants may deserve a jury trial.
4.    B/r judged are appointed for 14 years and are appointed by court of appeals in each circuit—so Art. I judges.