The Fifth Circuit adopted the reasoning of the crane footnote (fn 37) by limiting the amount realized from non-recourse debt relief to the FMV of the taxpayer’s encumbered property.  This contradicts the part of Crane that treats relief from non-recourse the same as relief from recourse.  This is because the economic benefit when a taxpayer is at risk only to the extent of the value of the encumbered property, the economic benefit on the disposition of the encumbered property can equal only the value of the property.  The Tufts court reasoned that a debtor has no economic incentive to pay an amount in excess of the value of the property that would be lost on default—the economic benefit is limited to the elimination of a possible claim against the value of the property transferred.