Doesn’t apply to rulemaking(See American Horse Protection Assoc. v. Lyn (1987): Org challenged failure to make regulation on horse soring devises and court remanded to give secretary chance to apply reason)
-rulemaking is different than adjudication because not akin to prosecutorial discretion; decisions turn on law rather than fact; and APA § 555e requires reasons
-But failure to act is not same thing as denial (See Norton v. S. Utah Wilderness Society (2004) – Blackboard: failure to make rule to prevent off-road vehicles from coming into parks is not reviewable under the APA because just a policy decision; didn’t consider rule and refuse to make it)
-relates to standing – can’t litigate generalized grievance