–     Rust v. Sullivan (1991):  This is a case that dealt with a federally funded program which explicitly limited the speech of the employees in the program as a condition of employment.  This case (and not the above cases) is only applied if the government restricts the speech of employees as part of a condition of receiving funding.  Thus, this case, unlike Pickering et. al., does not deal with how an employee’s speech affected the efficiency of the workplace.  (Title X grantees/doctors) challenged Title X of the Public Health Service Act (enacted in 1970) on the grounds that its provision—“none of the
funds appropriated under this subchapter shall be used in programs
where abortion is a method family planning”—violated Ps’ First Am.
rights along with the First Am. rights of the patients and staff at a
Title X clinic.  Specifically, Ps argue that the Title X provision impermissibly discriminated because it was based on viewpoint, since “all discussion about abortion as a lawful option” was prohibited, while discussion about other family planning options were allowed.  Did the Title X provision violate Ps’ First Am. rights by imposing “viewpoint-discriminatory conditions on government subsidies”?