Dissent (Scalia & al.):Brennan’s opinion requires that we overrule Hans, and he declines to do so. Whereas the post Civil War amends were avowed directly against the States (thus subject to waiver), the antecedent (prior) clauses were not. The 11th Am modified Art. III jurisdiction & the Comm. Cl. If there was an implicit waiver for that Art., then why not for all the others?