a)    Aetna sued the Department of Insurance, trying to preempt Senate Bill 386, which created liability provisions, established independent review of coverage determinations, protected physicians from HMO indemnity clauses.
b)    Aetna claimed the Act was preempted by ERISA.
c)    Court wanted to separate the plan into administrating responsibilities and delivery responsibilities.
(1)    The administrative responsibilities are preempted by ERISA b/c it determines the quantity of health care.
(2)    But the plan is covered by state law and it determines the quality of care, which would not be preempted by ERISA.  State law governs the delivery and quality of benefits as opposed to the quantity of benefits.
(a)    Vicarious liability was NOT preempted–if doctor is sued for the quality of care in the delivery of benefits.
d)    Independent Review Board is independent from the HMO plan.  The board was analyzed under McCarran-Ferguson Act.  The provisions establish a quasi-administrative procedures for the review of denials and binds ERISA to the decision of the board.  The scheme creates alternative mechanisms for its members to receive benefits, and that conflicts with ERISA’s remedies.
e)    HELD:  Malpractice cases and vicarious liability are NOT preempted by federal law.