The “falsely shouting fire in a theater” metaphor:  This metaphor holds to the extent that it illustrates that speech depends on context and circumstance.  But there are some problems with the metaphor:  It is not clear that D in Schenck falsely said anything and, more importantly, there is a difference between political speech and just shouting “fire!” (there is strong argument that First Am. protects political speech more than non-political speech).