Incandescent Lamp Patent (C4P5)
(A)    Sawyer and Man (S&M) get patent for incandescent conductor made of carbonized fibrous or textile material. Edison then comes along, finds out particular form of bamboo works the best, buys it up. Issue: Does S&M’s successes with carbonized paper and wood carbon allow them to claim all fibrous or textile material?
(B)    Court here thought a major defect for their patent was not doing the work to say what property of fiber works best. Lot of experimentation left otherwise. Edison brought something to the table.
(1)    S&M didn’t give us the lamp, someone else solved vacuum issue. All they brought was a substance that worked as a filament.
(2)    Different then pencil claim where inventor is giving us the pencil.
(C)    W/o Edison this isn’t an easy case of whether to reject on lack of enablement. It feels broad – every possible fibrous/textile material, but not as slam dunk as with Edison.