
Incandescent Lamp Patent (C4P5)
(A) Sawyer and Man (S&M) get patent for incandescent conductor made of carbonized fibrous or textile material. Edison then comes along, finds out particular form of bamboo works the best, buys it up. Issue: Does S&M’s successes with carbonized paper and wood carbon allow them to claim all fibrous or textile material?
(B) Court here thought a major defect for their patent was not doing the work to say what property of fiber works best. Lot of experimentation left otherwise. Edison brought something to the table.
(1) S&M didn’t give us the lamp, someone else solved vacuum issue. All they brought was a substance that worked as a filament.
(2) Different then pencil claim where inventor is giving us the pencil.
(C) W/o Edison this isn’t an easy case of whether to reject on lack of enablement. It feels broad – every possible fibrous/textile material, but not as slam dunk as with Edison.
We have located some similar legal questions and legal question categories. Check out these challenging questions that askquestions about Patent Law and are similar to What do you mean by Incandescent Lamp Patent?. Also, we have included a list of some of our more popular legal question categories. These categories are based on what everyone is asking and answering.
What's Your Answer to "What do you mean by Incandescent Lamp Patent?"