Limits on Prosecutorial Discretion
Did the decision to charge violate the suspect’s right to Equal Protection?
Selective Prosecution – C says VERY HARD to establish
you were selected but others were not (easy)
impermissible grounds (fundamental interest or suspect classification … hard to establish motive, cant’ get into the mind of the prosecutor)
Wayte – Selective Service Registration a “beg policy” … only know who you are if you speak up;
decision to prosecute generally rests in prosecutor’s discretion
prosecution not based on the basis of their speech, just prosecutorial efficiency
Where crack penalty much more severe than powder leads to lots more Blacks being prosecuted, USSC held not abuse
The RARE successful Selective Prosecution Case:
Falk – counselor for evading draft arrested for draft evasion; actual statement by prosecutor that was why he was being prosecuted established a prima facie case (then burden shifts to government)
Victims – usually need cooperation, but sometimes (ex. in DV cases) will go forward even if don’t