Ripeness
-Test (Abbott Laboratories v. Gardner (1967): Congress amended Food, Drug & Cosmetic Act to require prescription drug manufacturers to print name EVERY time – court said issue is ripe for resolution; no reason to believe review will delay enforcement)
(1) fitness for judicial consideration
(2) hardship of withholding review
-Compare Toilet Goods Assoc. v. Gardner (1967): Regulations permitting inspections not ripe for review
-SC distinguishes on grounds of uncertainty (no idea how regulation affects parties in Toilet Goods, but result is clear in Abbott) and primary conduct not affected
-JM – unless you need further factual development to understand how regulation going to be applied, get review
-SO court won’t be better informed in individual compliance proceedings
-See Ohio Forestry v. Sierra Club (1998) (could not challenge regulations that made “logging more likely” but did not authorize logging because issue not ripe)
-availability of alternative relief relevant (NYSE v. Bloom – could bring private action)
-JM thinks better to enforce first, sue later, so argument not abstract
-if criminal prosecution, definitely ripe so only issue is exhaustion