Critiques about judicial review
-advantages
-ensuring individual justice
-maintaining rule of law
-legitimating the administrative state
-democraticizing bureaucratic choices among competing values
-irrelevant – only matters to individual cases
-impertinent – not able to do things it says it can
-Winter critique – b/c only decide ?s of law, allow board to submerge legal decisions as decisions of fact to evade review
-JM’s proposal
-only review rulemaking at enforcement
-for adjudicatory systems set up quality assurance system to sample – certain percentage and criteria
-if they find problems, focus attention on correction of problems (e.g., evidence not good enough)
-judicial review of how running system
-could also have safety valve for certain types of cases (e.g., constitutional claims; statute that applies to multiple agencies)